Where to Open a Health Savings Account and What Each Option Offers
Banks, brokerages, and insurers all offer HSAs — choose based on investment options and fees
You can open a Health Savings Account through a bank, an investment brokerage, your health insurance company, or a dedicated HSA provider. The main difference is what you can do with the money once it's in the account: some providers let you invest it in stocks and mutual funds, while others keep it in cash or low-yield savings. Your choice depends on whether you plan to use the money soon or let it grow over years, and how much you're willing to pay in fees.
You don't have to open your HSA where you get your health insurance, even though your insurer may offer one. Shopping around takes an hour and can save you hundreds in fees over time. The account itself is yours — you own it and can move the money to a different provider later if you find better terms.
Key Takeaways
- Banks offer HSAs with FDIC protection but usually no investment options and higher monthly fees than brokerages.
- Investment brokerages let you buy stocks and mutual funds inside your HSA, which matters if you're saving for retirement rather than near-term medical costs.
- Health insurance companies often waive or reduce HSA fees for their members, making them competitive even if investment options are limited.
- Dedicated HSA providers like HealthEquity and Lively specialize in HSAs and often have lower fees and better tools than banks.
- You can change HSA providers at any time without penalty, so starting with one provider doesn't lock you in.
Banks and credit unions
Opening an HSA at your bank is straightforward if you already have a checking or savings account there. Most banks offer HSAs as a savings account with a debit card attached, so you can pay medical bills directly from the account. The money stays in cash or earns a small amount of interest — you cannot buy stocks or mutual funds.
Bank HSAs come with FDIC insurance up to $250,000, which means your money is protected if the bank fails. However, banks typically charge $3 to $10 per month in maintenance fees, and some charge per transaction or per debit card use. Over a year, these fees can add up to $36 to $120, which eats into your tax savings if you're not depositing much money.
Credit unions sometimes offer HSAs with lower fees than banks, especially if you're a member. Call your credit union and ask whether they offer HSAs and what the monthly fee is. Some credit unions waive the fee entirely for members who maintain a minimum balance.
Investment brokerages
Brokerages like Fidelity, Vanguard, and Charles Schwab let you invest HSA money in stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and exchange-traded funds (ETFs). This matters most if you're in your 30s or 40s and don't plan to spend the HSA money on medical bills for years — you can let it grow tax-free and use it for retirement medical costs later.
Brokerage HSAs usually have lower monthly fees than banks, often $0 to $3 per month, because the brokerage makes money from investment commissions and account management rather than charging you directly. Some brokerages waive HSA fees entirely if you maintain a minimum balance, typically $1,000 to $5,000.
The trade-off is that brokerages are less convenient for paying routine medical bills. You may need to transfer money to a checking account first, or use a debit card that has daily spending limits. If you plan to use your HSA for immediate medical costs, a bank or dedicated HSA provider is usually easier.
Health insurance companies
Your health insurer may offer an HSA as part of your plan enrollment. Insurers often waive monthly fees for members, making their HSAs competitive on cost even if they don't offer investment options. Some insurers partner with a third-party provider (like HealthEquity or Conduent) to run the account, so you're actually opening the account through that provider, not directly with the insurer.
The advantage of opening through your insurer is convenience: your insurer can tell you which medical bills are covered, and some can send claims directly to your HSA for payment. The disadvantage is limited choice — you get whatever HSA product your insurer offers, and if you switch insurers, you may need to move your account.
Check your insurer's enrollment materials or call their customer service line to find out whether they offer an HSA, what the fees are, and whether investment options are available. Don't assume the insurer's HSA is the cheapest option just because it's offered to you.
Dedicated HSA providers
Dedicated HSA providers like HealthEquity, Lively, and Catch focus only on HSAs, so they've built their platforms around HSA rules and features. These companies typically offer low or no monthly fees, investment options, and tools to track medical expenses and find in-network providers.
HealthEquity is the largest dedicated HSA provider and works with many employers and health insurers. Lively is known for low fees and a simple interface. Catch offers HSAs with investment options and integrates with tax software. Each has different fee structures and investment menus, so compare them if you're opening an HSA on your own rather than through an employer or insurer.
Dedicated providers are often the best choice if you're self-employed or buying health insurance on your own, because they don't tie you to an insurer and they usually have lower fees than banks. If your employer or insurer offers an HSA through a dedicated provider, that's often a good deal — you get the low fees without having to shop around.
What to compare when choosing a provider
Before opening an account, compare these four things: monthly fees, investment options, debit card features, and customer service. A provider with $5 per month in fees costs you $60 per year, which is real money if you're depositing $500 or less annually.
If you plan to invest the money, check what funds or stocks the provider offers. Some brokerages let you buy anything; others limit you to their own funds or a small menu. If you plan to pay medical bills directly from the account, test whether the debit card has daily limits or transaction fees that would frustrate you.
Call or email customer service with a question before you open the account — this tells you how responsive they are if you need help later. Some providers have live chat or phone support; others only offer email. If you're not tech-savvy, responsive support matters.
How to move your HSA to a different provider
You can move your HSA from one provider to another without taxes or penalties. The process is called a trustee-to-trustee transfer, and it takes two to four weeks. Contact the new provider and ask them to initiate the transfer — they'll handle the paperwork with your old provider, and you don't have to do anything except wait.
Some providers charge a transfer fee ($25 to $50) when you move money out, so check before you open an account. If you have investments in your old HSA, they may be sold and converted to cash during the transfer, which can trigger a small tax bill if the investments have grown. Ask your old provider what happens to investments before you start the transfer.
You can also do a rollover by withdrawing the money yourself and depositing it into a new HSA within 60 days, but this is riskier because you're responsible for meeting the deadline. Trustee-to-trustee transfers are safer and simpler.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I have more than one HSA at the same time?
No. If you have family or self-only health insurance coverage, you can only have one HSA. If you open a second one, the IRS treats the excess contribution as taxable income and charges a 6% penalty each year until you close one account. You can move money between accounts, but you cannot maintain two active HSAs simultaneously.
Do I have to open an HSA through my employer or insurer?
No. If your employer or insurer doesn't offer an HSA, or if their fees are high, you can open one on your own through a bank, brokerage, or dedicated provider. You'll need to make contributions yourself instead of through payroll deduction, but the tax benefits are the same. You must have a may have access to high-deductible health plan to contribute, regardless of where you open the account.
What happens to my HSA if I change jobs or health insurance?
Your HSA stays with you. The account is yours, not your employer's or insurer's, so you keep the money and can continue to use it even after you leave the job or switch plans. You can keep the account open with the same provider, or move it to a new provider if you prefer. You just need to make your own contributions going forward instead of through payroll.
Can I use my HSA debit card everywhere, or only at medical providers?
HSA debit cards can be used at any merchant, but the IRS only allows you to withdraw money tax-free for may have access to medical expenses. If you use the card for non-medical purchases, you owe income tax and a 20% penalty on that amount. Some providers flag purchases at non-medical merchants and ask you to confirm they're medical expenses; others don't. Either way, you're responsible for using the card correctly.
What if I want to invest my HSA but my current provider doesn't offer investments?
Move the account to a brokerage or dedicated provider that does. A trustee-to-trustee transfer takes two to four weeks and costs nothing (unless your old provider charges a transfer fee). Once the money arrives at the new provider, you can invest it in stocks, mutual funds, or other options they offer. There's no limit to how many times you can move your HSA, so don't stay with a provider that doesn't meet your needs.